Syntactic Awareness and Reading Comprehension: What the Research Says

When I lead professional development on syntactic awareness, there’s always someone (usually a coach or an administrator) who asks, “Okay, but what does the research say?”

Fair question. Here’s the plain-language version of what research says about syntactic awareness and reading comprehension, plus writing: what we know, where the evidence is strongest, and what it means for your classroom.

(If you need a quick definition first, read What Is Syntactic Awareness?)

1. Syntax is part of reading comprehension

In Scarborough’s Reading Rope (2001), the model so many schools use to explain skilled reading, “language structures” is one of the strands of language comprehension. That strand includes syntax: how words are arranged into sentences that carry meaning.

In other words, a child can decode every word in a sentence and still not understand it if they can’t untangle how the sentence is built. Think of a sentence like The fox that the hen chased ran into the woods. Who ran? Readers with strong syntax know.

Research: syntactic awareness and reading comprehension are closely related (Literacy How)

2. Syntactic awareness is linked to comprehension

Researchers have studied this connection for decades. A few studies I come back to:

  • Literacy How, summarizing the research, describes a close relationship between syntactic awareness and reading comprehension: as students learn to use more complex sentences when they talk and write, their understanding of what they read grows too.
  • Wolf, Gottwald and colleagues (2009) described a two-way street: kids who are exposed to more sophisticated written sentences comprehend better and know more about syntax, and kids with strong syntactic knowledge are better at understanding complex sentences.
  • Mokhtari and Niederhauser (2013) studied 5th graders and found that vocabulary and syntactic awareness each contributed to reading comprehension. Students who were weak in both struggled most with comprehension.
  • Cain (2007) studied 8- and 10-year-olds and found syntactic awareness was tied to both word reading and comprehension, with vocabulary and memory playing a role in the comprehension link.

The honest takeaway: syntax isn’t the only thing behind comprehension. Vocabulary and background knowledge matter a lot. But syntax is a real piece of the puzzle, and it’s one we rarely teach on purpose.

Research: students with syntactic awareness can hear a sentence that is wrong and fix it

3. Traditional grammar instruction doesn’t improve writing

This is the finding that surprises teachers most. In Writing Next (Graham & Perin, 2007), a major review of writing research for grades 4–12, traditional grammar instruction (explicitly teaching parts of speech and sentence diagramming, in isolation) had a small but statistically significant negative effect on the quality of students’ writing.

That echoes what Michelle Navarre Cleary wrote in The Atlantic in 2014: nearly a century of research shows that drilling grammar in isolation hasn’t helped students become better writers.

Grammar matters. Teaching it disconnected from real sentences is what doesn’t work.

4. Sentence combining does work

In the same Writing Next report, sentence combining was one of the eleven practices shown to improve student writing. Sentence combining is exactly what it sounds like: take two or more short sentences and combine them into one. It’s one of the most researched sentence-level strategies we have, and it’s the heart of my Sentence Stacking routine.

The difference is simple. Traditional grammar asks students to take sentences apart and label them. Sentence combining asks them to put sentences together and decide what sounds best.

5. It works like phonemic awareness, but for sentences

Gillis and Eberhardt (2018) make a comparison I love: students build phonemic awareness by manipulating sounds in words, and they build syntactic awareness by listening to, saying, reading and writing sentences until they realize that word order changes meaning.

That’s why my routines are short, daily and oral. Repeated exposure is the point, and it’s especially powerful for young children and students learning English, because syntactic awareness can be built out loud before students are fluent writers.

Syntax routines map: sentence detective, stacking, anagrams, switch-a-word, time travel, build-a-sentence, complete me
Short, daily routines, the way phonemic awareness drills work for sounds.
View this post on Instagram

6. One honest caution: connect it to real reading and writing

Not every study of syntax training has found big gains. For example, Layton, Robinson and Lawson (1998) found that syntax training improved students’ syntactic awareness but didn’t, on its own, improve their overall reading scores.

My read on that: isolated drills of any kind have limits. That’s why I don’t treat syntactic awareness as a separate subject. We use sentences from our science lesson, our social studies text and our read-aloud, and students learn to use the routines as revision strategies in their own writing. The transfer is the goal.

Tips for implementation: embed in content, watch language around culture, connect to revision, scaffold for language learners

What this means for your classroom

  • Protect 5–10 minutes a day for sentence work.
  • Make it active: combining, expanding, unscrambling, changing tense, not labeling.
  • Use real content: sentences from texts your students are reading and topics they’re learning.
  • Keep it talk-heavy so students hear the language.
  • Make the bridge to writing explicit, so routines become revision strategies.

If you want to see what that looks like, here are my 9 Syntactic Awareness Routines for K–5.

Here’s how I think about research-based practices, and why syntactic awareness made the cut in my classroom:

Bring this to your school

If you’re a coach or administrator looking to build syntactic awareness across your building, I’d love to help. Learn about professional development for schools and districts, including school licensing for the Reimagine Writing Program.

Until next time, happy writing!

References

  • Cain, K. (2007). Syntactic awareness and reading ability: Is there any evidence for a special relationship? Applied Psycholinguistics, 28(4), 679–694.
  • Gillis, M., & Eberhardt, N. C. (2018). Syntax: Knowledge to Practice. Literacy How.
  • Graham, S., & Perin, D. (2007). Writing Next: Effective strategies to improve writing of adolescents in middle and high schools. Alliance for Excellent Education / Carnegie Corporation of New York.
  • Layton, A., Robinson, J., & Lawson, M. (1998). The relationship between syntactic awareness and reading performance. Journal of Research in Reading, 21(1), 5–23.
  • Literacy How. Syntax. https://literacyhow.org/syntax/
  • Mokhtari, K., & Niederhauser, D. (2013). Vocabulary and syntactic knowledge factors in 5th grade students’ reading comprehension. International Electronic Journal of Elementary Education, 5(2), 157–170.
  • Navarre Cleary, M. (2014, February). The wrong way to teach grammar. The Atlantic.
  • Scarborough, H. S. (2001). Connecting early language and literacy to later reading (dis)abilities: Evidence, theory, and practice. In S. Neuman & D. Dickinson (Eds.), Handbook of Early Literacy Research.
  • Wolf, Gottwald, et al. (2009), as cited in Gillis & Eberhardt (2018).

Feeling stuck in your writing block?

Free training: Fix Your Writing Block

In my free on-demand training, Fix Your Writing Block, you’ll find what’s draining your writing time, see where student progress breaks down, and learn the shift that fixes it. Watch at your own pace and get a free K-5 writing unit.

Watch the Free Training

Not sure where to start? Take the 2-minute Writing Block Quiz.

SHARE:

Leave a Reply

What’s really breaking your writing block?

Take the free 2-minute quiz. You’ll find the one thing to fix first, plus a 3-step plan to start this week.

Writing Block Diagnostic Mockup

Rock Your Writing Block in 4 Easy Steps!

Enter your email below to download this free guide and get access to my exclusive newsletter with the latest news, insights, and resources.

Rock the Writing Block mockup image

By subscribing above you’ll be added to the newsletter list. You’re welcome to unsubscribe at anytime. We don’t do spam. We collect, use and process your data according to our Privacy Policy.